Access & re-use Linked (open) data Rights & privacy Metadata

Period

September 2022 - September 2023

DO IT! Supervising the identification of public domain materials

Since 2021, the Public Domain Tool has made it much easier for collection management organisations to determine the rights status of their collections, but more extensive use of the tool is not yet possible. In DO IT! we’re helping nine organisations to cross the proverbial threshold of using the Public Domain Tool to identify as many of their collection items as being in the public domain as possible. At the same time, we’re also finding out about the rights status of works on artinflanders.be.

Challenge

The most straightforward heritage to make accessible online is heritage that belongs in the public domain. After all, this is not (still) subject to copyright protection. Intellectual property rights are a complex matter, however, and even with the necessary knowledge it’s a time-consuming job to determine the rights status of each collection item. This means that an awful lot of digitised cultural heritage is not currently optimally accessible online, even if it isn’t subject to copyright restrictions. And that’s a great pity, which is why we launched the Public Domain Tool in 2021 to help organisations.

This tool allows collection managers to identify in a semi-automatic way collection items that belong in the public domain. Users who find their way to the tool are generally very satisfied with it, but unfortunately this group is still rather small. A lack of time and technical knowledge, along with management system limitations, creates a stumbling block to getting started with the tool for many collection management institutions. We’re tackling these obstacles together with nine organisations in DO IT!

Pictured: Flower market in Menton (Côte d’Azur), Anna De Weert, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Additionally, we’re also focusing on collection items – originating from some 60 Flemish museums and heritage organisations – that have been photographed over recent years for our art and heritage database, artinflanders.be. The rights status for some of these works is still currently a question mark, but we’re aiming to set that record straight in this project.

Our role

Two of our main knowledge domains come to the fore in this project: metadata (we create metadata about the rights status of objects) on the one hand, and rights and privacy on the other. We’re using the Public Domain Tool to help nine organisations check whether their works are in the public domain. If they are still protected by copyright, we indicate exactly when they will enter the public domain – as long as the date of the creator’s death or date of creation is known.

We’re doing this for and together with:

  • Ghent Archive: 7,500 items and 70 creators

  • Jakob Smitsmuseum: 600 items and 60 creators

  • M Leuven: 6,000 items

  • Museum Dhondt-Dhaenens: 700 items and 277 creators

  • Museum van Deinze en de Leiestreek - mudel: 1,025 items

  • Musea Brugge: 1,380 items, plus 7,000 items and 900 creators

  • Mu.ZEE: 4,000 items

  • S.M.A.K. (Municipal Museum of Contemporary Art in Ghent) 1,712 items and 663 creators

  • STAM (Ghent City Museum): 2,500 items and 150 creators

  • Image content from some 60 Flemish museums and heritage organisations on artinflanders.be: 31,000 items (of which 10,000 are suspected to overlap with Flemish Art Collection and the other collections above) and 2,637 creators 

  • The former VKC Flemish Art Collection (now also part of meemoo): crosscheck 40,000 creators with the collections above and image content on artinflanders.be

This project forms part of our work for Public Domain Day, an event that we’ve been running every year since 2018 – with the aim of highlighting the fact that copyright protection expires at the end of the year for certain collection items, which means they can enter the public domain from 1 January. We also organise an annual rights workshop and upload workshop as part of Public Domain Day.

Pictured: Public Domain Day 2020, Geertivp, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Approach

Because heritage is widely dispersed among large to very small organisations, we adopt a differentiated approach. There are three scenarios:

  1. Meemoo takes the lead in using the Public Domain Tool with the partner’s collection data. In this case, the partner allows us to add data to their management system. The rights check on artinflanders.be also uses this method.

  2. Meemoo takes the lead in using the Public Domain Tool with the partner’s collection data. The partner then validates the output from the Public Domain Tool, decides which data to add to their management system, and registers it there themselves.

  3. The partner takes the lead but can always rely on our support. They use the Public Domain Tool and add the data to their own management system themselves.

There is also a lot of overlap among the creators of works in our participating partners’ collections, and among images on artinflanders.be. The former VKC – as a central point for museum collections – made collection data available from their affiliated art museums. This gives us explicit access to data from museums that are not taking part in this project themselves, and allows us to gather extra overlapping details about creators.

Additional project benefits

  • Because the Public Domain Tool makes use of open data from Wikidata, it’s possible to enrich the participating collection management partners’ collection data even further. If their collection management system allows, the participating partner can use the Public Domain Tool to easily include the Wikidata identifier as well as identifiers for other databases (such as VIAF, RKD and ULAN). 

  • And vice versa, the Public Domain Tool will itself also supplement data about creators in Wikidata with data from the project partners, so that these details are available for everyone as linked open data. The functioning of the Public Domain Tool will improve as more and richer data about creators becomes available on Wikidata. Win-win!

Results

The DO IT project reached its conclusion in September 2023. Here are some noteworthy figures:

A total of 69,363 collection items were processed through the Public Domain Tool as part of this project, and we discovered that approximately 40% of these are currently in the public domain, equating to 28,215 collection pieces.

A significant number of additional collection pieces will join the public domain over the coming years as copyright protection expires. In 2024, the works of 309 creators will enter the public domain, followed by the works of 119 creators in 2025, 65 creators in 2026, 155 creators in 2027, 372 creators in 2028, 164 creators in 2029, and a substantial 888 creators in 2030. 

Public Domain - Copyright protected - Unknown

Improvements to the Public Domain Tool

Throughout the project, the intensive use of the Public Domain Tool highlighted several areas for attention. We have therefore improved the tool in the following areas:

  • management of taxonomy in the backend;

  • calculation of rights status and the public domain date;

  • functionality of the bot that writes collection data to Wikidata.

The tool’s performance will continue to improve in the future as more comprehensive and detailed data about creators becomes available on Wikidata – because the collection data is still being written to Wikidata using the Public Domain Tool’s bot.

We are also exploring the feasibility of more future enhancements, in particular focusing on:

  • the user-friendliness of the Public Domain Tool;

  • simplifying the integration of results into source systems;

  • refining the suggested matches from Wikidata;

  • improving the quality of data written to Wikidata.

Partners

We’re running this project in close collaboration with the former VKC - Flemish Art Collection (now meemoo), M Leuven, Museum Dhondt-Dhaenens, Musea Brugge, Mu.ZEE, S.M.A.K. Municipal Museum of Contemporary Art in Ghent, STAM Ghent City Museum, Museum van Deinze en de Leiestreek - mudel, Jakob Smitsmuseum and Ghent Archive.

Do you have a question?
Contact Bart Magnus
Expertise Officer
This page is loading...